Yrsa Sigurðardóttir is the Icelandic queen of the crime thriller

When I interviewed Yrsa Sigurðardóttir, she was already one of Iceland’s most celebrated crime writers. Yrsa is a civil engineer by profession who somehow also found time to become the country’s reigning queen of Nordic noir. Since then, the international recognition has only grown.

Yrsa was the second-most-sold crime writer in Iceland in 2025, with her stand-alone thriller, “Syndafall,” hitting number one on Iceland’s official hardcover bestseller list upon publication. Salomonsson Agency’s 2025 English-language release, The Wake, the second entry in the Black Ice series, was named one of the best Nordic books of 2025, praised for its slow-building tension set against the remote Westman Islands and described as cementing her reputation as the Queen of Icelandic Noir. Nordic Watchlist: A third Black Ice novel, The Depths, is due in 2026. Her books have now been translated into more than thirty languages.

What makes this interview worth your time is something no international press profile captures: a native Icelander talking to a local writer about where Iceland’s darkness actually comes from — the landscape, the history, the long winters, and what it does to the imagination.

That conversation is below.

Icelandic author Yrsa Sigurðardóttir is a master of the gritty crime novel. And sometimes, her books veer into the supernatural. For me, her books are an essential part of the Christmas season. Here in Iceland, the period before Christmas is known as the Christmas book avalanche. Books are a popular Christmas present, and authors and publishers compete for the top spots on the best-seller’s list. And that is where Yrsa dominates for a good reason. Her books rival masters such as Stephen King, and I have spent many late nights shuddering while enjoying her latest page-turners. Thank you, Yrsa, for all the chills!

One of the stars of the Iceland Noir Literature Festival

Yrsa is one of the founders and hosts of the Iceland Noir Literature Festival. This takes place in Reykjavik from 16th to 19th November. She joins authors such as Richard Osman, Ragnar Jónasson, Bernardine Evaristo, and Marian Keyes. First Lady of Iceland, Eliza Reid, the author of the book Secrets of the Sprakkar: Iceland’s Extraordinary Women and How They Are Changing the World, and the star of Trapped, Ólafur Darri Ólafsson, also participate in the festival. Last but not least, the Prime Minister of Iceland, Katrín Jakobsdóttir, a budding crime novel author, will appear at the festival.

Tickets to the Icelandic Noir Literature Festival

Get your tickets to the festival

Hello Yrsa, and thank you for taking the time for this interview. First of all, thank you for all the great books you have written. What is the secret to a good crime novel?

What makes a crime novel great can be many things, depending on the reader’s taste. Irrespective of the sub-genre, the book must have engaging characters, an exciting plot, and a well-presented sense of place – and course, be well-written prose-wise. My tastes lean towards the macabre and creepy. This means that something horrible is always a big plus for me, as well as twisted events that make total sense when the veil is lifted, and you go: “Ah! Of course.”

Be the all-powerful author

The secret to doing this is realizing that you, the author, control everything. The weather, all occurrences, the characters’ thoughts, words, and actions – everything. Unlike living one’s life, where all you can control is what you do and say. Writing is, therefore much easier.

Make a believable plot

The trick of making strange things happen on the pages without the readers rolling their eyes is not making them coincidental. They must at some point seem somewhat logical, i.e., they must be underpinned so as not to happen out of the blue and appear ridiculous. If you, as an author, need a duck to fall out of the sky onto someone’s head, then make sure that this falling duck can be expected from what has occurred or been described earlier. I have, however, never needed to revert to ducks falling out of the sky. But you never know. Maybe I will take this reply as a challenge for my next book.

What Icelandic authors do you want to recommend to my readers?

Oh, that is an easy one. Ragnar Jonasson and Eva Björg Ægisdóttir are my favorites.

Do you have favorite places or activities in Iceland you want to recommend to my readers?

Personally, my favorite place is the Westman Islands. It is a small fishing town on Heimaey, the largest island in an archipelago off the south coast of Iceland. The Westman Islands are famous for the birth of a new volcano in 1973. It erupted out of a farmer’s field in the middle of the night. The eruption engulfed a good chunk of the town under lava and the rest under ash. The ash was removed. However, lava destroys everything in its wake and remains. A house or two sticks out of the jagged wall at its boundaries. But the view from the island is fantastic as the surrounding ocean is littered with smaller islands that rise high out of the sea, themselves remnants of ancient eruptions common in the area. But if you are visiting Iceland for the first time and don’t fancy a ferry ride, you cannot go wrong with the south coast. It is a must-see.

Favorite waterfalls, beaches, and waterfalls

There you can experience waterfalls (my favorite is Gljúfrabúi -closely followed by its next-door neighbor Seljalandsfoss, Geysir and Strokkur in Haukadalur (on the way, although not exactly on the south coast), black beach Reynisfjara (do not get sucked away by the creeper waves), glacial lagoon Jökulsárlón and mystical Stokksnes and Vestrahorn.

Other tips would include a trip to an outdoor swimming pool, and if you want to do it fancy and enjoy a glass of bubbly while at it, the Sky Lagoon in Kópavogur (in the Reykjavík area) just opened up and is really nice. Note that you will not swim at all there, just relax.

What advice do you have for those visiting Iceland for the first time?

Dress for any kind of weather, irrespective of the season. This is best emphasized by an old advertising slogan of 66°N – an Icelandic outdoor wear company. The slogan was: “This is our winter collection, also known as our summer collection.” We never put away our parkas here; they can be called for in the height of summer; you just never know. Also, if you are not vegan or vegetarian, order fish at restaurants. Here in Iceland, we serve fish minus the yucky parts, such as the head, the scales, and the bones. Wolffish never disappoints.

Enjoy langoustine, ice-cream and swimming

Icelandic lobster tails are also really good, although they are not actually lobster but langoustine. You will not need an apron or special tools that make you feel like some awful torturer while ripping off claws and breaking shells. This has been done for you. And finally, have ice cream from an ice cream parlor, a local favorite all year round, a remnant from the time we had very little imported candy. Recap: dress well, enjoy nature, swim, and eat.